Crumb Cake

SKU:
$17.25
$17.25
Unavailable
per item
Our world famous crumb cake!
Choose from our old standard of plain cake topped with our famous struesel and finished with powdered sugar or icing. 

This page is for SHIPPING products ONLY
If you would like to order for curbside pickup or local delivery,
please visit the curbside pickup/local delivery page under the Ordering tab drop-down menu

Irish Soda Bread

$7.25
Why wait until St. Patrick's Day?  One of the best tasting Irish Soda breads you will ever have.  Available all year.
Each bread serves approximately four generous servings.
Order extra to save on shipping costs.  (Freezes great)
Shop

Pudding Cakes

$14.83

Your choice of apples, blueberries, cherries or harvest (blueberries, cherries, apples, peaches, and walnuts) baked in our delicious, moist, dense, yellow cake (similar to pound cake)...topped with our famous streusel crumbs and drizzled with fondant icing. 

Each pudding cake serves approximately 7 - 9 people.
Shop

Oatmeal Carmel Cookie Bars with Chocolate Chips - (4 pack)

$18.16

Oatmeal Caramel Bar with Chocolate Chips
Shop

Assorted Specialty Bars - (4 pack)

$19.16

We have turned some of our favorite treats into these delicious bars!

Flavors:

Pecan Nut Bar dipped in Chocolate

Raspberry Macaroon Bar dipped in Chocolate

"Superfood" Bar (macaroon base with sliced almonds, craisins, pumpkin seeds, oats, and sunflower seeds)
Shop

Cookie Decorating Kit

$8.25 - $24.75

Each kit comes with plain round sugar cookies (either 2, 4, or 6 count) with 3 assorted buttercream icing bags and 3 bags of assorted sprinkles/candies. Kits cannot be customized at this time.
Shop

Caffe Vita 12oz Coffee

$18.15
Shop

Crumb Cake

$17.25
Our world famous crumb cake!
Choose from our old standard of plain cake topped with our famous struesel and finished with powdered sugar or icing. 
Shop

Filled Crumb Cake

$17.25
Our famous crumb cake that is filled with blueberry or raspberry.
Shop

Just Mueller's Crumbs - 1.5lb bag

$19.95

Now you can purchase the best part of our famous crumb cake. Just the crumbs! Each bag is one and a half pounds of deliciousness. These "Just Mueller's Crumbs" are dairy and egg free/ vegan.
Shop

Schnibblins: Dairy Free and Egg Free Brownies - (4 pack)

$17.60

A 4-pack of our in-house specialty baker's egg free and dairy free delicious chocolate brownies!Vegan friendly.

*Subject to availability. We will contact you with substitutions if needed.
Shop

Schnibblins Sunbutter Buddies - 2pk

$4.35

Gluten Free, Dairy Free, Egg Free

*Subject to availability. We will contact you with substitutions if needed.
Shop

Mueller's Bakery Stainless Steel Water Bottle

$15.99

20 oz. Light Blue Stainless Steel Water Bottle with Mueller's Bakery logo (in black and lavender) on one side and Mueller's Bakery Bay Head, NJ Scene (in black) on the other side. Hand wash only
Shop
1 2 3

We are happy to provide online shipping.
Our method of shipping is through USPS Priority Mail (2-3 day shipping)
Please keep in mind we ship our products fresh and make sure we bake it for your order. 
In that regard we can not offer same day shipping.  We ship Tuesday - Saturday.
If you place your  order before 3pm we will ship the next day.  Any orders placed after 3pm will be shipped in two days.
Of course you may leave in the special instruction section a future date you would like the crumb cakes shipped if immediate shipping is not your preference. 
If you would like to include a note please do so in the gift option section. 

732 892-0442