Due to the overwhelming volume of orders,
please take note of our newest protocols:

SAME DAY orders (excluding Easter Weekend) will be accepted AFTER 9AM.
Please call 732-892-0442 and keep trying until you get through and have your order and payment information ready. 
There will be a wait of 15-30 minutes minimum, possibly longer during peak hours. 
Same day is pickup only, no deliveries

To place FUTURE PICKUP orders (next day or longer), we strongly encourage you to use the website to place your order by 4:30pm for next day, any orders after 4:30pm will be ready in 2 days. If you cannot use the website, please call in your future order between 1-5pm (mornings are too busy at the moment)

To place DELIVERY orders (next day or longer only, no same day deliveries) please use the website to place your order and add the “local delivery address” item to your cart with the address where the order is to be dropped; $25 minimum and 10 mile radius.  Orders must be placed by 4:30 for next day, any orders after 4:30pm will be ready in 2 days. Deliveries are porch drop off only, we will ring the bell or knock.  We cannot guarantee a delivery time, we start late morning

PICK UP your order AFTER 8AM and when you arrive please:
TEXT: 732-569-5149 with the name on the order
OR CALL: 732-892-0442 and let us know you are here and the name on the order

Store Hours (curbside pickup only, doors are not open to the public):
Tuesday-Saturday 8am-5pm
Easter 8am-1pm
Closed Mondays

***Please order from the curbside pickup/delivery page not the shipping page***
Shipping orders(From the shipping page) are shipped through USPS Priority Mail.

What are your hours?

Hours can be found under the Contact Us page

What is your refund policy?

If you are unsatisfied with your purchase bring your item back.  We will review the concern and issue a store credit or a refund at our discretion.

I have a nut allergy, can I still buy something?

Due to cross contamination, we cannot guarantee that anything we sell is completely nut-free.  Many of our products do not contain nuts so if the allergy is not severe, it may be safe, however if the allergy is severe we recommend going to a bakery that specializes in allergy-free products.

I have a gluten allergy or sensitivity, can I still buy something?

Due to the nature of flour, it is difficult to prevent cross-contamination between our products.  We do carry items that do not contain gluten in the recipe, however if the allergy is severe we recommend going to a bakery that specializes in gluten-free products.

I would like to ship crumb cake, how does it work?

You can call the store, use our online ordering, or stop-in to place a shipping order.  Make sure you have the correct address you wish to send it to and if placing a phone order or online order, have your credit card information ready.  The cakes are shipped in plastic wrap and bubble wrap through the USPS Priority Shipping.  Cakes have successfully shipped across the world so no need to be afraid to ship.  Stock up to save on shipping and freeze the extras until you are ready for them.

Do you ship anything other than crumb cake?

Sure we do.  Visit our store page.  Don't see what your looking for?  Give us a call at 732 892-0442 and see if we can accommodate your request.Featured Products

I would like to have my wedding cake made by Mueller's, what do I need to do?

All wedding information can be found under the Wedding page.

I want to place an order for a holiday, will you be open and when should I place my order?

We are open on the following major Holidays: Easter, Thanksgiving, July 4th, Memorial Day, Labor Day
We are closed on Christmas Day and the day after.
We are closed January 1st through mid-February.
All holiday orders must be placed no later than two days before the holiday, no exceptions.
I have a donation request.  How do I go about getting Mueller's to donate?

Here at Mueller's we honor many organization's requests.  We ask that you make your request with a formal letter.  We also ask that you submit your request at least two weeks prior to your need.  We can not honor requests that do not give us enough notice.